Throughout Jane Austen's Persuasion, observations arise regarding the differences between the two genres. There is an ongoing debate between what is intrinsic to one genre and what is not in relation to the other. Anne's observations on the subject often challenge the normality of what is accepted in her society. On many occasions, she makes assertions based on her own experiences rather than simply accepting the existence of a particular feminine or masculine essence. The theme of gender differences is most evident in the discussion between Anne and Captain Harville in chapter thirteen. In this scene, they freely discuss their opinions on fundamental differences between the sexes, thereby helping to highlight Austen's perception of controversy. Despite arguments made verbally for inherent nature, Austen attributes differences between the sexes to their place in society and their experiences within it. Say no to plagiarism. Get a Custom Essay on “Why Violent Video Games Should Not Be Banned”?Get Original Essay Anne and Harville engage in a debate over which gender forgets love first and which gender loves longest . They each argue on behalf of their respective gender, beginning with Anne's opening statement: "We live at home, quiet, confined, and our feelings overwhelm us. You have to make an effort. You always have some profession, some activity, some business of one kind or another, which immediately brings you back to the world, and continued occupation and change soon weaken the impressions” (164). Anne's initial comment emphasizes the effect of societal expectations on each gender. She asserts that because men are allowed to engage in activities and work, they should have no reason to meditate solely on their feelings. Her comment is progressive because it explains the gender stereotype that women are emotional rather than claiming it is simply a matter of nature. Harville contributes to his point by reminding him that not all men have the capacity to work. He states that his theory "does not apply to Benwick." He was not forced to make any effort” (164). Benwick is therefore a perfect example of how experience shapes traits rather than gender. Because he has no apparent purpose in society as workers do, he is free to ruminate on his emotions in the same way women do. Anne refutes her own argument from the natural experiment by presenting the opposite, saying: “If change does not come from external circumstances, it must come from within; it must be nature, the nature of man” (165). By asserting the contrary, she may be drawing a comment from Harville that casts in uncertain light the theory that genres have an inherent emotional range. Harville says: “I believe the opposite. I believe in a true analogy between our bodily frameworks and our minds; and that as our bodies are the strongest, so are our feelings; capable of withstanding the harshest uses and resisting the harshest weather” (165). Such a statement seems insane; there is no evidence that physical and emotional strength are directly correlated. Because their arguments in favor of nature have no substance, Anne returns to a point of view of experience: "You have enough difficulties, privations and dangers to fight... It would indeed be too hard if the woman's feelings were added to it. all of this” (165). She states that because in society work is man's burden, emotions.