blog




  • Essay / Discussion of whether torture is an acceptable method of obtaining intelligence data

    A journalistic resource (2017) stated that: "During the administration of George W. Bush, the CIA used this which she called “enhanced interrogation techniques” on detainees around the world. world. This included waterboarding (simulated drowning), sleep deprivation to the point of hallucination, beatings, sexual humiliation, and threats to harm an inmate's children or rape an inmate's mother. Does torture work and should we use torture to obtain intelligence data? What is the Christian view on the use of torture? Using these questions, this essay will provide numerous resources to help determine whether torture is an acceptable method to use on detainees captured for interrogation and, most importantly, to protect our country's national security. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on 'Why violent video games should not be banned'? Get the original essay Top government investigators have explained that torture and abuse during interrogation of detainees is not the answer more effective in gathering reliable and truthful information. Does torture work? In-depth interrogations are not about getting people to talk, but rather about gathering reliable information in order to protect our nation's citizens from radical attacks on American soil. The CIA's Enhanced Interrogation Techniques programs are dangerous, life-threatening torture techniques designed to break a detainee's will in order to gather information that the detainee would not otherwise provide, information that would prevent imminent significant harm to citizens. Interestingly, until September 11, the CIA's position was that torture was ineffective and the information provided was unreliable. This is supported by the 2014 report of the US Senate Select Committee on Intelligence on Detention Status and Enhanced Interrogation Techniques, which states that "the use of CIA enhanced interrogation techniques was not not an effective means of obtaining accurate information or gaining cooperation from detainees” and “CIA interrogations of detainees were brutal and far worse than the CIA represented to policymakers and others.” These techniques, whether legal or not, destroy our country's image in the world and incite anger and revenge when combined with existing feelings of excess, authoritarianism, occupation, of police and military abuses and tyranny. Our enemies can use evidence of these abuses in their propaganda, with legitimate events lending credibility and sympathy to their cause. Understand the need to find information and find it quickly, but if by discovering or obtaining information to prevent one attack we then fuel three more attacks, that's a Pyrrhic victory. Even more so when the information obtained is, at best, unreliable. It is written in 1 John 3:18 “Dear children, let us not love in word or speech, but in deeds and in truth,” so let us be consistent in our words and deeds, so as to avoid impropriety and give ammunition to our enemies. to use against us. Although torture has been shown to be less effective, there are many ways a country can attempt to defeat terrorism. Our manual states that "They include (1) crushing terrorist groups unilaterally, (2) crushing terrorist groups multilaterally, (3) containment, (4) defense, (5).